Infrastructure · 20 November 2026 · 5 min read
Seven-State Ratepayer Coalition and Market Monitor Urge PJM to Delay December Capacity Auction Over Data Center Costs
Consumer advocates and Monitoring Analytics want PJM to strip speculative data center forecasts from its December auction, warning canceled projects could add another $5 billion to $10 billion in customer bills.

Lede & Nut Graf
Ratepayer advocates from seven states—Ohio, Delaware, West Virginia, Maryland, Pennsylvania, New Jersey, and Illinois—have joined PJM Interconnection’s Independent Market Monitor, Monitoring Analytics, in urging PJM’s board to postpone its December 2026 base capacity auction (Utility Dive, Nov. 19, 2026; MLQ.ai, Nov. 20, 2026). The coalition requested a written response from PJM’s board by Monday, November 23, 2026.
The standoff escalates a high-stakes battle over who pays for artificial intelligence (AI) power demand across PJM’s 13-state, 67-million-customer footprint. With wholesale electricity prices surging, state advocates argue that running the December auction under current rules will force residential and commercial ratepayers to subsidize billions of dollars in speculative data center load.
Technical & Financial Breakdown
The coalition’s letter builds directly on Monitoring Analytics’ November 12, 2026 State of the Market report, which concluded that PJM’s capacity auctions for the 2025/2026 through 2028/2029 delivery years were "not competitive, primarily as a result of the inclusion of forecast demand for data centers" (Monitoring Analytics, Nov. 12, 2026).
According to the market monitor, folding existing and forecast data center demand into PJM’s capacity market has already caused an irreversible $29.4 billion increase in capacity costs for all customers. Monitoring Analytics further estimated that canceled or unlikely data center projects remaining in PJM’s load forecast could saddle customers with an additional $5 billion to $10 billion in unnecessary costs if the December auction proceeds as scheduled. Meanwhile, PJM’s real-time load-weighted average locational marginal price (LMP) climbed 48.4% year over year during the first nine months of 2026, jumping from $50.51 per megawatt-hour (MWh) to $74.98/MWh.
Rather than merely trimming load forecasts, the advocates and market monitor want PJM to exclude forecast data center demand from the base capacity auction altogether and require large loads to bring their own new generation or secure bilateral contracts via a separate reliability backstop procurement.
Second-Order Implications
The coalition’s push—amplified by Exelon Corp.’s November 3 complaint at the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC)—lands alongside today’s November 20 FERC show-cause filing deadline for the Southwest Power Pool (SPP), the sixth and final regional transmission organization (RTO) submitting large-load interconnection reforms.
For independent power producers (IPPs) like Constellation Energy, Vistra, and Talen Energy, a delayed auction or removal of speculative data center load from PJM’s demand curve could cool forward capacity clearing prices in the near term, even as bilateral behind-the-meter and co-located power purchase agreements (PPAs) grow more valuable.
Caveats & Open Questions
PJM is pushing back hard: spokesman Jeffrey Shields warned that postponing the auction this close to execution "could destabilize the market," and any formal delay would require emergency FERC approval. Whether PJM’s board yields by the November 23 deadline—or proceeds with its December auction under revised planning parameters—will set the tone for Mid-Atlantic power pricing and hyperscale data center permitting heading into 2027.
More in Infrastructure